Skip to Content

Elements of a Product Liability Claim

case file that says "Defective Product" with judge gavel on top

Defining Product Liability

Legal Framework for Product Liability

Understanding the legal landscape of product liability is crucial for anyone affected by a defective product. At its core, product liability law is designed to protect consumers from harm caused by dangerous products. The legal principles that underpin product liability include negligence, where a manufacturer fails to exercise reasonable care; strict liability, which holds manufacturers accountable for defects regardless of care level; and breach of warranty, which focuses on a product's failure to fulfill its stated promises. These frameworks ensure that consumers have a path to compensation when products do not perform safely.

Types of Product Defects

When a product causes harm, it's essential to identify the type of defect responsible. There are three main categories: design defects, which are inherent flaws present before the product is made; manufacturing defects, which occur during the construction or production phase; and marketing defects, also known as failure to warn, where the product lacks adequate instructions or warnings about its use. Each type of defect can lead to serious injuries, and understanding the distinctions is key to building a solid product liability claim.

Establishing the Basis for a Claim

Proving Negligence in Product Liability

For those injured by a defective product, proving negligence is one path to establishing a claim. This requires demonstrating that the manufacturer did not take the care that a reasonable entity would have under similar circumstances, leading to the creation of a harmful product. The burden of proof lies with the claimant, who must show that this lack of care resulted in the product's defectiveness. This can be a complex process, necessitating a thorough understanding of the standards to which manufacturers are held.

The Role of Strict Liability

In contrast to negligence, strict liability offers a different avenue for claimants. Under strict liability, the focus is on the product's defectiveness rather than the manufacturer's conduct. If a claimant can prove that the product was inherently defective and that this defect led to their injury, they may have a valid claim, regardless of whether the manufacturer was negligent. This principle underscores the importance of product safety and the manufacturer's responsibility to ensure that their products do not pose undue risks to consumers.

The Claimant's Burden of Proof

Causation and Injury

One of the most challenging aspects of a product liability claim is establishing causation. The claimant must demonstrate a direct causal link between the product defect and the injury sustained. This involves not just showing that the product was defective, but that this defect was the proximate cause of the injury. Without clear causation, even the most obvious product defects may not lead to a successful claim. It's a nuanced process that often requires expert testimony to articulate how the defect led to the injury.

Evidence and Documentation

Building a compelling product liability case hinges on the strength of the evidence presented. Claimants must gather comprehensive documentation, which may include design schematics, testing materials, manufacturing documents, expert analysis, medical records detailing the injuries, and proof of purchase to establish the product's ownership. Photographs of the defective product and the injury, as well as any recall notices or other consumer warnings, can also be pivotal. This evidence forms the backbone of the claim, illustrating the defect, the harm caused, and the connection between the two.

Defenses in Product Liability Cases

Contributory and Comparative Negligence

Even with a strong case, claimants should be prepared for potential defenses from the manufacturer. One common strategy is to allege contributory or comparative negligence, suggesting that the claimant's own actions played a role in the injury. Depending on the jurisdiction, this could lead to a reduction in the damages awarded or even a dismissal of the claim. Understanding these defenses and how they might apply to a particular case is essential for claimants and their legal representatives.

Misuse of the Product

Another line of defense that manufacturers may employ is misuse of the product. If the defendant can prove that the claimant used the product in a manner not intended or foreseeable by the manufacturer, they may evade liability. This defense highlights the challenges that can arise when claimants deviate from prescribed usage guidelines.

Resolving Product Liability Claims

Settlement Negotiations and Mediation

Not all product liability claims need to end up in court. Settlement negotiations and mediation often provide alternative paths to resolution. These processes allow both parties to discuss the claim's merits and negotiate compensation without the need for a trial. Mediation, in particular, involves a neutral third party who helps facilitate a mutually agreeable solution. For many, these out-of-court options can be less stressful and more cost-effective, leading to quicker resolutions.

The Litigation Process and Trial

When settlement is not an option, the litigation process becomes the path forward. This formal legal process involves several stages, including filing a lawsuit, discovery, expert depositions, pre-trial motions, culminating in jury selection and a trial. Each phase is critical and requires meticulous preparation, from gathering evidence to presenting a compelling case in court. For claimants, understanding these stages is vital to navigating the complexities of a product liability lawsuit effectively.

Greene Broillet & Wheeler, LLP

If you or someone you know in El Segundo, CA, has been injured by a defective product, the experienced attorneys at Greene Broillet & Wheeler are here to help. Our team is dedicated to ensuring that you receive the compensation and justice you deserve. Contact us today to discuss your case and learn how we can assist you in navigating the intricacies of product liability law. Let us put our expertise to work for you.